Is it OK to feed a feathered friend in your palm? Our resident expert says yes, but only in the right circumstances.
It is well known that certain bird species can be enticed to take various kinds of food items right out of your hand. Bluebirds, chickadees, jays and nuthatches, to name a few, can be trained to take mealworms or seeds from your palm. You can feed several hummingbirds at once from sugar water held in your hand.
But just because we can, does that mean we should? Here are my thoughts.
Allow me to first draw my lines in the sand.
First, I am against offering mice, live or dead, to any bird of prey for any reason, because the raptor being fed could end up associating all humans with food offerings, a bad thing for all concerned. What’s more, certain species, like barred owls, that will take live mice from the hand also are known to strike humans while defending their nests. Besides potential physical injury to both parties, you can imagine the lifelong trauma suffered by a child after such an attack. And there’s the reputational damage to raptorial birds in the public eye at a time when they need our protection. It has also been shown that feeding raptors live prey near a road can lead to collisions with vehicles.
Second, I am opposed to hand-feeding ducks, geese, swans and gulls in parks and especially on public beaches. Besides their growing numbers annoying beachgoers, their copious feces in the water can cause disease like Escherichia coli in bathers. I speak from experience. Gulls and swans can also become dangerously aggressive.
Third, feeding threatened or endangered species from the hand is not recommended. For instance, supplementing the food of endangered Florida scrub-jays may harm their breeding success by affecting the timing of fledging their young. So, when is it OK to hand-feed birds? Well, since we already offer various healthy foods to our backyard birds via our feeders, I personally see no wrong in them getting food from our hands too. What about hand-feeding birds in public parks? I know of no scientific studies supporting the notion that these birds become entrained to expect to be fed and then stressed in some manner when food is not forthcoming. I believe birds that willingly come to humans, whether it be to a feeder or a hand, merely treat them as fast-food outlets, always reverting to natural foods when available.
I leave you with one last example — offering breadcrumbs, cheese, raisins, granola or pet kibble to Canada jays (hopefully, our future national bird) at a road stop, at a campsite or on a hiking or ski trail. While this activity evokes much pleasure and even nurtures a love for nature, experiments conducted in Algonquin Park by Dan Strickland, Canada’s foremost expert on the species, also demonstrated that “providing winter supplements causes breeding jays to raise more and healthier nestlings.” As for such out-of-ordinary foods perhaps being harmful to the jays, Dan tells me that “Canada jays normally subsist all winter on semi-rotten bits of raw, vertebrate flesh, insects, spiders, berries and mushrooms, and all in various stages of decay, especially if there have been winter thaws that encourage even more than the usual amount of bacterial growth.” If that won’t hurt them, would a raisin?
My bottom line on the question of hand-feeding birds is that until further studies have been done, offering healthy food in your hand to various non-aggressive songbirds in public greenspaces or in your backyard is not likely to cause them any harm. Moreover, the benefits (again, to all parties) appear to outweigh the risks.